Combining SIPOC with the Cause-and-Effect Diagram

	Bookmark This Page Email This Page Format for Printing Cite This Article Submit an Article Read More Articles
	Related Tools & Articles Categories of Legitimate Reservation Focuses Fishbone Determine the Root Cause: 5 Whys The Cause-and-Effect Diagram (a.k.a. Fishbone)
	Discussion Forum "...should (one) have to use all the 'traditional' Six Sigma tools for a project to be considered 'Six Sigma'? Is there a minimum number of tools required for a project to 'pass' a tollgate in your company?" Contribute to this Discussion

B

New from iSixSigma Practical Tools for Continuous Improvement E-book Vol.2 NEW VERSION! Lean Six Sigma Champion Training Root Cause Analysis Course

y Sean C. Rast

Six Sigma practitioners strive to find the root causes of defects fast and accurately. One of the tools that provides a good initial view of the process Six Sigma is being used to optimize is the SIPOC (supplier-input-process-output-customer). This tool is especially helpful when the improvement project is aimed at a process with which the project leader has little to no experience.

The SIPOC can assist in completing the project charter in numerous ways. The suppliers and customers are potential team members and/or stakeholders, the outputs are the metrics which will be used to measure the project, the inputs allow the project team to consider various potential critical Xs, and, of course, the process itself provides the stop-start barriers.

Cause-and-Effect Diagram and Six M's

Once the charter is complete and signed by all parties, the team transitions to the Measure phase, where the search starts for potential Xs that influence output. One of the tools is the fishbone diagram. The classic cause-and-effect fishbone has the defect at the end (the stinky head of the fish), and the bones are split up in six categories:

1. Man (People)
2. Machines
3. Material
4. Methods
5. Measurements
6. Mother Nature

Figure 1: Fishbone with Six M's

With each "bone," the team tries to find various potential Xs that influence the project Y by asking:

• "How does Man (People) negatively influence the defect?"
• "How do the Machines negatively influence the defect?"
• "How does the Material negatively influence the defect?"
• "How do the Methods negatively influence the defect?"
• "How do the Measurements negatively influence the defect?"
• "How does Mother Nature negatively influence the defect?"

After completing this exercise, the team should have various inputs that can be classified as the six bones. The project team may have more inputs on the material bone, or have more on the people one, but in the end the team will have an idea of where the critical X could be. The next step then is to sort and prioritize the various Xs and start measuring them in conjunction with the Y.

Using Process Steps in Fishbone

Another way to use the fishbone diagram to search for potential Xs is to combine it with the SIPOC. During the construction of the SIPOC, the team lists between four and eight high-level process steps. Now, instead of using the standard bones (man, machine, material, methods, measurements and Mother Nature), the team uses the process steps listed in the SIPOC.

Figure 2: Fishbone with Process Steps

The list of questions remains the same:

• "How does Process Step 1 negatively influence the defect?"
• "How does Process Step 2 negatively influence the defect?"
• And so forth.

Doing this has several benefits:

1. The project team can identify and associate with the process steps more easily than with the generic bones.
2. Due to this association, the team can normally think of more inputs than with the generic bones.
3. After completing the fishbone with the process steps, it is really easy to pinpoint where the problem may be occurring.

By combining the cause-and-effect diagram and the SIPOC, a Green Belt or Black Belt will quickly and more effectively find which critical Xs actually influence the project Y.

About the Author: Sean C. Rast is an associate with Valeocon Management Consulting, who is based in Frankfurt, Germany. He has worked directly and indirectly with companies such as Textron, Compaq/HP, Magna, VW, BMW, Chrysler-Mercedes, and other automobile manufacturers. Mr. Rast is a certified Master Black Belt with both Design for Six Sigma and DMAIC expertise. He has extensive international experience and can communicate in English, German, Swiss-German and Swedish. He can be reached at sean.rast@valeocon.com.